Avoiding Double Taxation on Investment Income

Bureaucracy Without Pain, as told by an international tax advisor

Introduction – the hidden fee nobody talks about

You’ve scrutinised fund expense ratios down to the fourth decimal place. You’ve optimised currency conversion costs after reading our piece on timing big foreign-exchange transfers. Yet, if you hold investments while living or working across borders, the real silent killer of returns is often double taxation.

In plain English: two different tax authorities each try to collect tax on the same dividend, coupon or capital gain. If your net yield is 4 %, giving up 30 % twice obliterates almost half of it. And unlike market volatility, this hit is entirely avoidable—provided you understand the rules and claim the reliefs that already exist.

Below is the concise, no-nonsense playbook I share with globe-trotting clients—from UK software founders in Lisbon to Dutch highly skilled migrants (yes, the ones enjoying the 30 % ruling you may have met in our Netherlands migrant scheme guide).

1. Double taxation: what it is and why it matters

1.1 Dual claims on the same income

At its core, double taxation of investment income happens because:

1. Source country (where the company paying the dividend, bond coupon, or sale proceeds is based) withholds tax at origin.
2. Residence country (where you’re considered tax-resident) taxes your worldwide income—including that dividend—again.

If no relief is claimed, you can lose 40 – 60 % of gross returns on fully taxable income streams (see table).

1.2 Why it’s more frequent today

Remote work and location-independent portfolios make it easy to create “accidental” double taxation:

• International brokers automatically allocate US ETFs.
• Start-ups grant RSUs tethered to Delaware companies.
• You move to Spain halfway through the tax year.

Absent active planning, the result is a messy cocktail of withholding taxes, foreign tax credits and—in worst cases—disallowed deductions because you filed the wrong form.

“Tax rules are national. Your life is global. The gap in between is where leakage happens.”

2. Step-by-step process to neutralise double taxation

2.1 Confirm your tax residence

Everything flows from where you are considered tax-resident. The tests differ (days present, centre of vital interests, permanent home). If you have two potential residencies, most treaties apply the tie-breaker rule—usually your “habitual abode.” Nail this down first.

2.2 Identify applicable tax treaties

1. Retrieve the double tax treaty (DTT) between your residence country and each source country of income.
2. Focus on articles covering:
3. Dividends
4. Interest
5. Capital gains
6. Note reduced withholding rates—e.g. US–UK treaty drops US dividend withholding from 30 % to 15 %.

Practical tip: Bookmark an official source (OECD, IRS treaty tables) instead of random blogs that can be outdated.

2.3 File the source-country relief form before income is paid

• US shares? Non-US residents must file Form W-8BEN with their broker—zero cost, five minutes online, valid for three years.
• Australia? Use Form 1173 to claim treaty benefits at source.

Failing to do this pushes the burden to your residence return (credit claim later), delaying refunds by 12+ months.

2.4 Claim foreign tax credit (FTC) or exemption in your residence return

If withholding still occurred, you normally get a dollar-for-dollar credit against domestic tax. Checklist:

• Verify the credit is limited to the lower of foreign tax paid or residence tax on the same income.
• Attach certificates of tax withheld (your broker’s year-end statement sometimes suffices).
• Keep original statements for five years; many tax offices audit FTC claims long after refunds.

2.5 Consider treaty-qualified holding structures

For sizeable portfolios, or if you draw income from multiple jurisdictions, evaluate:

• Ireland-domiciled ETFs for US equities – exploit 15 % treaty rate at the fund level instead of 30 % direct.
• Luxembourg SICAV for EU bonds – no withholding.
• Local tax-deferred wrappers (UK ISA, Australian superannuation, 401(k)) – reduce residence-level taxation.

2.6 Re-engineer the income stream

Dividends trigger withholding; unrealised gains don’t. Two common moves:

1. Switch to accumulating (capitalising) share classes – the fund reinvests internally, no distribution = no withholding.
2. Hold growth stocks and harvest gains only when your residence country offers a lower rate (e.g. year of departure).

2.7 Keep currency in mind

Residence tax is calculated in local currency. Fluctuations between accrual and payment dates can change creditable tax, so:

• Record exchange rates on both transaction and payment date.
• Use officially published rates (central bank or tax authority) to avoid disputes.

3. Costs and timelines

3.1 Monetary outlays

Personal view: Below €5k annual gross foreign income, DIY with software is defensible. Above that, the fee for a good advisor usually pays for itself.

3.2 Time budgets

1. Initial classification & treaty mapping – 2–4 hours.
2. Source-country forms – 15–30 min per jurisdiction, every three years.
3. Residence tax return FTC section – 30 min if software, 2–3 hours if manual.
4. Refund wait –
5. Via credit: immediate offset when return assessed.
6. Via reclaim: six months (Switzerland) to 18 months (France).

4. Common mistakes to avoid

4.1 Ignoring “passive foreign investment company” (PFIC) rules

US taxpayers abroad buying non-US funds face punitive PFIC tax, which no treaty overrides. Hold US-domiciled ETFs or direct shares instead.

4.2 Filing the wrong version of W-8

W-8BEN (individual) vs. W-8BEN-E (entity). Using the latter by accident stalls dividend payments; I see this every quarter with new LLC owners.

4.3 Overlooking partial-year residency splits

Move countries mid-year and each authority may tax your full-year income unless you invoke split-year treatment. Put it in writing; don’t rely on payroll to do it automatically.

4.4 Not matching income type with treaty article

Interest labelled as “bond discount” or “payment in lieu” may be taxed at higher rates. Ensure brokers code them correctly.

4.5 Waiting until filing season to discover withheld tax

By April the cash is gone. File relief forms at account opening, not after the first dividend hits.

5. Worked example: Maya, the roving product manager

Maya, a German national, lived in Singapore until June 2023, then moved to Spain on a digital-nomad visa. Her portfolio:

• US-listed Apple shares (dividends)
• Irish ETF tracking S&P 500 (accumulating)
• German government bonds (coupons)

She avoided double taxation as follows:

1. Confirmed Spanish residence for 2H-2023 via the 183-day rule.
2. Filed W-8BEN claiming US–Spain treaty 15 % rate on Apple dividends (done through Interactive Brokers).
3. Spanish tax software auto-credited the 15 % US withholding; no extra Spanish tax owed because dividends fall under Spain’s 19 % savings tax bracket and FTC capped liability.
4. Irish ETF: no withholding at source; taxed in Spain only.
5. German bonds: 0 % withholding under EU interest directive; taxed in Spain—again, no double hit.

Result: Zero double taxation, no refunds to chase, and only €120 spent on the Spanish version of TurboTax.

6. FAQs in 60 seconds

Do I need to be a treaty resident to claim foreign tax credit?
No. FTC exists under domestic law, but treaty residency often lowers or eliminates source withholding before you need the credit.

My broker withheld the full 30 % US tax despite my W-8BEN—what now?
Ask the broker to re-file the form and issue a corrected 1042-S. If not fixed by year-end, claim the credit on your residence return.

Can I get source tax refunded retroactively?
Usually yes, within statute limitations (3–5 years). Paper forms, proof of tax residency for that year, and original dividend statements are required.

7. Final checklist

Before the next distribution hits your account, run through:

• [ ] Confirm where you’re tax-resident this calendar or fiscal year.
• [ ] Download and skim the relevant treaty article.
• [ ] File the correct source-country form (W-8BEN, NR301, 1173, etc.).
• [ ] Ensure your broker knows your residency status.
• [ ] Keep digital copies of all withholding statements.
• [ ] Use tax software that supports FTC or hire a cross-border advisor.

Call-out: Bureaucracy doesn’t disappear—it just becomes painless when you follow a system.

Feeling lighter already? Let BorderPilot automate the heavy lifting. Create your free relocation plan now and see exactly which forms, deadlines and credits apply to your portfolio in the next country on your list.